×
≡Menu
Search
Home > Blog > Blog > Long Term Disability > ERISA Disability Claim Deemed Exhausted: Minnesota Federal Court Shuts Aflac’s Post-Litigation Documents Out of the Record

ERISA Disability Claim Deemed Exhausted: Minnesota Federal Court Shuts Aflac’s Post-Litigation Documents Out of the Record

In Coleman v. Continental American Insurance Company, No. 26-cv-0522 (ECT/DJF), 2026 WL 3458557 (D. Minn. Nov. 13, 2026), a federal magistrate judge reconsidered her own earlier ruling and closed the administrative record in an ERISA long-term disability case to documents the insurer created only after the claimant filed suit, documents the insurer generated after it let the regulatory decision deadline pass without ever acting on the claim.

What happened to Plaintiff’s ERISA disability claim?

Ecolab, Inc. hired Plaintiff in December 2022 as a Manufacturing District Representative III, a sales and account-management role that required sales meetings, cold calls, customer billing, and safety training. Ecolab offered long-term disability benefits through a group policy that Defendant Continental American Insurance Company, also known as Aflac, insured and administered. Plaintiff claims a July 2023 deer tick bite led to suspected Lyme disease, and he reported severe chronic fatigue syndrome with fibromyalgia pain, chronic headaches, intractable migraines, chronic abdominal symptoms, and cognitive impairment. His condition worsened, and he resigned effective September 30, 2024.

Plaintiff and his counsel contacted Aflac in March 2025 to start short-term and long-term disability claims. Aflac told him he did not qualify for short-term benefits because he no longer worked for Ecolab, sent him a letter about Family and Medical Leave Act eligibility, and said nothing about his long-term disability claim. Plaintiff submitted proof of loss on October 7, 2025. His counsel confirmed Aflac received the claim but could not get any status information despite repeated calls. On November 13, 2025, counsel notified Aflac that Plaintiff would treat the claim as exhausted if Aflac did not respond within seven days. Aflac did not respond. Plaintiff sued on January 21, 2026. Aflac did not open a review until after the lawsuit began and issued a formal denial on April 15, 2026.

How did the court find Plaintiff exhausted his ERISA remedies?

The court held that Defendant did not strictly follow 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(f)(3), which requires a decision within forty-five days of a disability claim unless the administrator notifies the claimant of a needed extension. Defendant never gave notice of an extension, so its decision was due no later than November 21, 2025. As of that date, Plaintiff’s claim was exhausted, he could sue, and Defendant was deemed to have denied the claim without exercising discretion, so de novo review applied. See Firestone Tire & Rubber Co. v. Bruch, 489 U.S. 101 (1989). The court also found the exception for trivial violations did not save Defendant, because the delay prejudiced Plaintiff and Defendant did not begin its review until after Plaintiff sued, so no ongoing, good-faith exchange of information existed.

Why did the court refuse to expand the ERISA administrative record?

Defendant conceded that Plaintiff’s claim was exhausted and properly before the court on de novo review but argued good cause existed to add the documents it generated after litigation began. The court agreed that district courts can expand the record on de novo review for good cause, but explained that the Eighth Circuit focuses on whether the party seeking to add evidence had an opportunity to present it during the administrative proceedings. See Proctor v. Unum Life Insurance Co. of America, 2022 WL 4585278 (D. Minn. Sept. 29, 2022) (quoting Sloan v. Hartford Life & Accident Insurance Co., 475 F.3d 999 (8th Cir. 2007)). Defendant had ample opportunity to investigate and present evidence and failed to do so. At the hearing, Defendant’s counsel conceded there was no good explanation for the failure to act on the claim.

The court rejected Defendant’s reliance on Weber v. Saint Louis University, 6 F.3d 558 (8th Cir. 1993), and held that de novo review alone does not justify expanding the record. See Farley v. Hartford Life & Accident Insurance Co., No. 4:24-cv-00894-SEP (E.D. Mo. Sept. 30, 2026). The court also rejected Defendant’s argument that excluding the documents would strip the court of the information underlying the benefits decision. The benefits decision rested on the deemed denial that occurred by operation of law on November 21, 2025, not on anything that happened after Plaintiff sued, so the post-litigation documents were unnecessary to understand it. The record already contained the policy, documents on Plaintiff’s job duties, accommodations, and resignation, his treating physician’s Attending Physician’s Statement and addendum, medical records from December 2022 through December 2025, the claim forms, and witness statements including one from Plaintiff’s spouse. That record gave the court enough to decide the claim on the merits, so good cause to add the post-litigation documents was lacking.

What did the court order?

The court granted Plaintiff’s motion in part and denied it in part. It granted the request to exclude the post-litigation documents, ordering that, absent the parties’ agreement, materials Defendant introduced after Plaintiff filed suit stay out of the record. It denied as moot Plaintiff’s request to include documents Defendant had already agreed to include.

SHARE THIS POST:

facebook twitter shop

*Please note that this blog is a summary of a reported legal decision and does not constitute legal advice. This blog has not been updated to note any subsequent change in status, including whether a decision is reconsidered or vacated. The case above was handled by other law firms, but if you have questions about how the developing law impacts your ERISA benefit claim, the attorneys at Roberts Disability Law, P.C. may be able to advise you so please contact us.

Get The Help You Need Today

Inner form image

LEAVE YOUR MESSAGE

Contact Us

We know how to get your insurance claim paid. Call today at:
(510) 230-2090

Close Popup