×
≡Menu
Search
Home > Blog > Blog > Fiduciaries > Ninth Circuit Holds That Remand Would Be a “Useless Formality” Where Claimant Showed No Prejudice from Blue Shield’s Alleged Failure to Engage in a Meaningful Dialogue and Rejects Her Fiduciary Breach Claim

Ninth Circuit Holds That Remand Would Be a “Useless Formality” Where Claimant Showed No Prejudice from Blue Shield’s Alleged Failure to Engage in a Meaningful Dialogue and Rejects Her Fiduciary Breach Claim

In Jill T. v. California Physicians’ Service, No. 24-7344, 2026 WL 3549109 (9th Cir. Nov. 18, 2026), the Ninth Circuit affirmed the district court’s judgment in favor of California Physicians’ Service, doing business as Blue Shield of California, on Plaintiff’s claim for benefits under ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B), 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(1)(B), and her claim for equitable relief for breach of fiduciary duty under ERISA § 502(a)(3), 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(3). Blue Shield denied coverage for inpatient mental health treatment that Plaintiff’s minor son, M.F., received at residential treatment facilities. The court reviewed de novo the district court’s choice and application of the standard of review, and reviewed its underlying factual findings for clear error, citing Abatie v. Alta Health & Life Insurance Co., 458 F.3d 955 (9th Cir. 2006) (en banc).

On the benefits claim, the court assumed that Blue Shield breached its duty under Abatie v. Alta Health & Life Insurance Co. to engage in a meaningful dialogue with Plaintiff before denying her claims, but held that the error was harmless. The court explained that a claimant harmed by a fiduciary’s failure to follow ERISA’s procedural requirements ordinarily receives no substantive remedy and at most receives a remand for reconsideration under proper procedures, citing Blau v. Del Monte Corp., 748 F.2d 1348 (9th Cir. 1984), and Ellenburg v. Brockway, Inc., 763 F.2d 1091 (9th Cir. 1985). Under Wit v. United Behavioral Health, 79 F.4th 1068 (9th Cir. 2023), however, the court declines to remand when reprocessing would be a “useless formality” because the administrator’s error did not prejudice the claimant or the claimant clearly was not eligible for benefits.

The court found that Plaintiff had not shown that Blue Shield’s errors prejudiced her ability to present evidence of medical necessity. During an external independent medical review before the California Department of Managed Health Care, which addressed only medical necessity, Plaintiff submitted thousands of pages of new evidence that Blue Shield had not previously considered. After considering that evidence, the Department concluded that M.F.’s treatment at certain residential mental health facilities was not medically necessary. In the district court, Plaintiff relied on the same expanded record to argue medical necessity, and she did not seek to supplement the record further, which she could have done under Friedrich v. Intel Corp., 181 F.3d 1105 (9th Cir. 1999). Reviewing the record de novo, the district court agreed with the independent medical review that Plaintiff had not shown the treatment was medically necessary. Jill T. v. California Physicians’ Service, 755 F. Supp. 3d 1228 (N.D. Cal. 2024).

Plaintiff’s opening brief on appeal expressly declined to challenge that factual finding, so the court held the challenge forfeited under Independent Towers of Washington v. Washington, 350 F.3d 925 (9th Cir. 2003). The court added that even if it considered the medical necessity arguments Plaintiff raised for the first time in her reply brief, those arguments did not show clear error, and Plaintiff offered no reason to believe Blue Shield would reach a different result on reprocessing. Because a remand would be a useless formality, the court affirmed the judgment on the benefits claim.

The court also affirmed the judgment on the fiduciary breach claim. Quoting Wit v. United Behavioral Health, which relied on Varity Corp. v. Howe, 516 U.S. 489 (1996), the court explained that § 1132(a)(3) is a catchall provision that allows appropriate equitable relief for injuries that § 1132 does not otherwise remedy. Plaintiff sought two remedies: reimbursement and reprocessing. The court held that reimbursement, which could be characterized as an equitable surcharge, requires a showing of actual harm caused by the fiduciary’s breach under CIGNA Corp. v. Amara, 563 U.S. 421 (2011), and Plaintiff made no such showing. As for reprocessing, Plaintiff did not explain or cite precedent showing that reprocessing was relief typically available in equity, as Wit v. United Behavioral Health requires.

SHARE THIS POST:

facebook twitter shop

*Please note that this blog is a summary of a reported legal decision and does not constitute legal advice. This blog has not been updated to note any subsequent change in status, including whether a decision is reconsidered or vacated. The case above was handled by other law firms, but if you have questions about how the developing law impacts your ERISA benefit claim, the attorneys at Roberts Disability Law, P.C. may be able to advise you so please contact us.

Get The Help You Need Today

Inner form image

LEAVE YOUR MESSAGE

Contact Us

We know how to get your insurance claim paid. Call today at:
(510) 230-2090

Close Popup