In Smith v. Reliance Standard Life Insurance Company, No. 1:25-CV-705, 2026 WL 3538327 (M.D. Pa. Nov. 17, 2026), the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania denied cross-motions for summary judgment in an ERISA long-term disability dispute and ordered the case to proceed to a bench trial under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 52, holding that genuine disputes of material fact over whether Plaintiff can perform full-time work prevent judgment as a matter of law for either side. Reviewing the claim de novo, the court found that the conflicting medical opinions in the record require credibility determinations and the weighing of evidence, tasks Rule 56 does not allow.
How did the dispute over Plaintiff’s ERISA disability benefits arise?
Plaintiff worked as a Sales & Marketing Support Specialist and was insured under a group long-term disability policy that Reliance Standard issued to Church of the Brethren Benefit Trust, which classified her occupation as sedentary. After a 2016 motor vehicle accident, she stopped working and reported headaches, neck and shoulder pain, and unsteadiness, and Reliance approved benefits beginning in November 2016. Her treating physician, Dr. Raymond Ruberg, treated her for post-concussion syndrome, cognitive impairment, muscle spasm, headaches, and unsteadiness. In 2018, Reliance’s clinical staff concluded that her chronic pain and visual complaints continued to support disability under the policy’s “Any Occupation” standard, and in 2021 the Social Security Administration found her disabled with an onset date in August 2019.
In late 2023, two Reliance reviewers concluded that Plaintiff appeared cognitively intact and could perform full-time sedentary work, and Reliance terminated her benefits effective January 4, 2024. Plaintiff appealed. Reliance then arranged an independent medical examination by Dr. Jason Brokaw, who opined that Plaintiff could sit continuously and perform continuous fine manipulation and keyboarding, that her complaints did not correlate to the benign nature of her objective studies, and that she should undergo a functional capacity evaluation. Stephen Uetz performed the first evaluation and placed Plaintiff below the sedentary demand level with a maximum six-hour workday. Dr. Brokaw questioned that evaluation because Uetz was apparently not a physical therapist and recommended a second one. Rachel Craig, P.T., performed the second evaluation, noting visual, auditory, cognitive, and balance dysfunction from post-concussion syndrome but summarizing Plaintiff’s performance as invalid and inconsistent. A psychiatric reviewer, Dr. M. Ashraf Ali, found no medically necessary psychiatric restrictions. Reliance upheld the termination in April 2025 after a vocational consultant identified five occupations Plaintiff could purportedly perform, and Plaintiff commenced this ERISA action later that month.
What standard of review governed the claim?
The parties agreed that the policy conferred no discretionary authority to determine eligibility or construe the plan’s terms, so the court reviewed the claim de novo under Firestone Tire & Rubber Co. v. Bruch. Under de novo review, the court determines whether the administrator made a correct decision and accords its determination no deference. The court emphasized, however, that de novo review does not displace Rule 56, so a court may not resolve genuine disputes of material fact on summary judgment. Because a participant proceeding under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(1)(B) has no right to a jury trial, the court may resolve any disputed factual issues at a bench trial under Rule 52.
Why did the court deny both motions for summary judgment?
The record contained materially conflicting medical opinions on whether Plaintiff can perform full-time work. A December 2023 Reliance reviewer found her capable of full-time sedentary work, while Dr. Ruberg limited her to four hours per day, reported that her condition had not changed in years, and attributed her apparent improvement to pacing rather than better health. Dr. Brokaw concluded she could perform at least sedentary work, Dr. Ali found no psychiatric limitations, and the two functional capacity evaluations conflicted, with Uetz assessing a six-hour maximum workday and Craig reporting invalid results. The policy’s “Any Occupation” definition considers an insured Totally Disabled if she can perform the material duties of a qualifying occupation only on a part-time basis, so the threshold question was whether Plaintiff can work full-time. Viewing the evidence in each party’s favor, the court found that a reasonable factfinder could reach either conclusion, and resolving that conflict would require weighing the evidence and assessing credibility, which Rule 56 forbids.
Did Reliance have to show medical improvement before terminating benefits?
No. Plaintiff argued that Reliance had to point to some improvement in her condition before reversing its earlier determination that she was Totally Disabled. The court disagreed, relying on Shaver v. Siemens Corp. for the principle that only the plan itself can create an entitlement to benefits. After the initial two-year period, Plaintiff was entitled to continuing benefits only if she kept satisfying the policy’s “Any Occupation” definition, so Reliance did not need to demonstrate medical improvement before terminating.
Could Plaintiff raise vocational objections she did not assert during the administrative appeal?
Yes. Plaintiff argued that she cannot perform the five occupations Reliance identified and that Reliance failed to follow its own methodology for evaluating transferable skills, and Reliance responded that she forfeited those objections by not raising them during the administrative process. The court held that ERISA requires exhaustion of claims, not every issue or theory supporting those claims, citing Wolf v. National Shopmen Pension Fund. Because Plaintiff exhausted her benefits claim by appealing the termination, her failure to raise specific vocational objections during the administrative process did not, standing alone, bar her from advancing those arguments in litigation.
*Please note that this blog is a summary of a reported legal decision and does not constitute legal advice. This blog has not been updated to note any subsequent change in status, including whether a decision is reconsidered or vacated. The case above was handled by other law firms, but if you have questions about how the developing law impacts your ERISA benefit claim, the attorneys at Roberts Disability Law, P.C. may be able to advise you so please contact us.

LEAVE YOUR MESSAGE
We know how to get your insurance claim paid. Call today at:
(510) 230-2090